and analysis, communication with complainants and respondent-attorneys, and legal writing. in fulfillment of ODCs mission to protect the public and ensure the integrity of the bar involving the performance of research Respondent presented the testimony of Dr. Kramer who testified to respondent's weekly psychiatric visits, mental diagnoses, and progress under treatment. The New Jersey Office of Attorney Ethics filed a complaint against respondent for making material misrepresentations and omissions on his New Jersey bar application and to the investigator. Before CAPPY, C.J., and CASTILLE, NIGRO, NEWMAN, SAYLOR, EAKIN and BAER, JJ. May 23, 2015, Pennsylvania Justices CASTILLE and BAER join this concurring and dissenting opinion. WebOffice of Disciplinary Counsel v. Preski, 635 Pa. 220, 134 A.3d 1027, 1031 (2016). %PDF-1.7
%
On June 5, 2001, the Disciplinary Board appointed a three-member hearing committee to hear respondent's case. Box 577, Helena, MT 59624. Use this button to switch between dark and light mode. Josh Shapiro, Governor Jennifer Selber, General Counsel. While respondent was on probation and contesting New York's reciprocal discipline, the California medical board lodged new accusations against him, charging that during his license probationary period, respondent engaged in grossly negligent or incompetent treatment of six patients, one of whom lost most of his eyesight. WebThe Office of Disciplinary Counsel (ODC) is the branch of the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania that investigates and prosecutes complaints of misconduct against Pennsylvania attorneys. Report of Hearing Committee 1.03, 6/10/03, at 21-22. Kramer and Sadoff testified to respondent's mental infirmities. hbbd```b``A$Sd="5"7d2dd &ie@!3"MY@f$k
61D As this sanction was not sought by Office of Disciplinary Counsel, we decline to impose it at this juncture. May utilize the assistance of staff (e.g. Fairness. The evaluation lasted about two hours, and following a second hour-long evaluation on May 19, 2000, Dr. Sadoff opined: Letter From Dr. Sadoff to Carl Poplar, Esq., 5/22/00, at 13. Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Pozonsky, Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Cappuccio, California Business and Professions Code 2261. Communicate with, and obtain relevant documentation from, third parties regarding allegations of misconduct. Case information . Below is a comparison between our most recent version and the prior quarterly release. Prepare dismissal letters, letters of concern or education, and other correspondence. May utilize the assistance of staff (e.g. 2457; amended April 18, 2019, effective in 30 days from date of publication, 49 Pa.B. ." Appeal from the Pennsylvania Office of Disciplinary Counsel. The Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania recruits, employs, and promotes the most qualified applicants without regard to their political The committee has now authorized Jessica Yates, the attorney regulation counsel, to file a formal complaint against Ellis with the presiding disciplinary judge, according to Yates. The Disciplinary Board rejected the recommendation of the Hearing Committee and held: "The Board's review of the record persuades us that this case requires disbarment." all applicants are given a fair and equal opportunity to compete for all employment positions. See Renfroe, at 404 (accepting causal connection between misconduct during addiction but still mandating disbarment). 204 (types of discipline available). (b)Disciplinary District Offices. state and federal laws governing fair and nondiscriminatory hiring and employment practices and are subject to change as necessary to Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Kanuck, 535 A.2d 69, 76 (Pa. 1987) (holding that where the attorney did not intend to embezzle his clients' funds and made restitution in every instance, a five year suspension was appropriate sanction). affiliation, race, color, age, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, religion, disability, or other non-merit Petitioner sought to impose discipline on the respondent for violating Pa. R. Prof. investigates and prosecutes complaints of misconduct against Pennsylvania attorneys. No statutes or acts will be found at this website. Dr. Sadoff also testified and endorsed Dr. Kramer's findings and diagnosis, stating: "Clearly in my opinion within a reasonable medical certainty [respondent's mental infirmities coupled with his then-present emotional pressures] were a substantial factor and the reason why [respondent] answered [the questions on the bar application] the way he did." Casetext, Inc. and Casetext are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice. On April 3, 2001, the Pennsylvania Office of Disciplinary Counsel (ODC) filed a petition for discipline charging respondent with violations of Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct 8.1(a) and 8.4(b)-(d). 204 Pa. Code 85.5. Bulletin, Vol 49, No. The provisions of this 85.5 amended through August 30, 1985, effective August 31, 1985, 15 Pa.B. Knowledge of state and federal laws, particularly in regard to disciplinary administration. Ability to work effectively with supervisors and fellow employees. The New Jersey disciplinary hearing was held June 26, 2000, and Drs. Communicate with respondents to obtain information or documentation relevant to an investigation or to resolve matters. 7348 (November 26, 2022). Consideration is to be given to any mitigating factors that are present. However, this Court undoubtedly has the inherent power to revoke a license granted in the first place under this Court's rules and authority. an interview should request so in advance. Respondent conceded he made errors on the application, but attributed them to confusion; he alleged he thought he was to list only undergraduate schools and degrees, and claimed he did not list his medical disciplinary proceedings because he thought each had been dismissed and administratively expunged. In his answer, respondent admitted making the serial falsehoods and "that at the time such statements were made he knew that each such statement was false." Conduct 1.7 requires attorneys to avoid conflicts of interest in the representation of WebDescription: The Office of Disciplinary Counsel (ODC) is the branch of the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania that investigates and prosecutes complaints of misconduct against Pennsylvania attorneys. The Disciplinary Board, however, has recommended this Court not only disbar respondent, but immediately revoke his license to practice law; this would require respondent to reapply for the bar examination, pass the Board of Law Examiners' character and fitness evaluation, and pass the bar examination before being eligible to seek reinstatement following his five-year disbarment. WebOffice of Disciplinary Counsel 201 Merchant Street, Suite 1600 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Phone: (808) 521-4591 For access to Traffic cases; District Court, Circuit Court, and Family Court criminal; District Court, Circuit Court civil, and Family Court civil; Land Court and Tax Appeal Court; and appellate court case information. Skill in analyzing and drafting legal documents, legal instruments, and other work product. Only by requiring Respondent to begin the admissions process ab initio can we be assured that he has the requisite fitness and character to be a member of the bar. Each of the appellate courts and September 28, 2019, Pennsylvania Bulletin, Vol 49, No. Dr. Sadoff reviewed the results of the tests and the opinion of Dr. Kramer and ultimately agreed with Dr. Kramer's diagnosis. Graduation from an approved school of law, PLUS progressively responsible experience in professional legal work. Philadelphia, Trooper, Harrisburg, or Pittsburgh office, remote work is available for many of the positions duties. The Board commented: "The quantity and quality of [r]espondent's lies over such a long period of time is unlike anything witnessed by this Board in previous cases." The This Court followed the Board's recommendation that the established mental disorder and requisite causal connection to the misconduct, coupled with the underlying facts of Braun's case, justified suspension rather than disbarment. Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Surrick, 561 Pa. 167, 749 A.2d 441, 449 (2000) (citation omitted). UJS hiring and employment policies and procedures are intended to conform to all applicable September 28, 2019, Pennsylvania Code (Rules and Regulations), Title 204 - JUDICIAL SYSTEM GENERAL PROVISIONS, Subpart C - DISCIPLINARY BOARD OF THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA, Chapter 93 - ORGANIZATION AND ADMINISTRATION, Subchapter D - OFFICE OF DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL, 204 Pa. Code 93.63 - Powers and duties of Office of Disciplinary Counsel. Respondent represented Pennsylvania State University (Penn State) and three of its administrators during grand jury proceedings investigating matters relating to child abuse accusations against a former assistant football coach. Review docket entries, pleadings, and other documents relevant to assigned files. 0
WebThe location of the headquarters of the Office of Disciplinary Counsel and the office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel is: Office of Disciplinary Counsel. Perform other related duties and responsibilities as required and/or assigned. 601 Commonwealth AvenueP.O. No statutes or acts will be found at this website. %%EOF
Part or full time depending on language demand. 21. . Id. Respondent filed an answer to the complaint which contained and compounded the original misrepresentations and omissions. He was licensed to practice medicine in New York after completing his residency in internal medicine at Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia; he also completed a residency in ophthalmology surgery. Candidates interested in applying for this position are requested to submit a written resume and cover letter in .PDF format System. Communicate with respondents to obtain information or documentation relevant to an investigation or to resolve matters. PARTIES TO DISCIPLINE ON CONSENT 1. WebOffice of Disciplinary Counsel v. Baldwin | Case Brief for Law School | LexisNexis Law School Case Brief Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Baldwin - 657 Pa. 339, 225 A.3d 817 (2020) Rule: Pa. R. Prof. WebMembers of the Commission shall attend an orientation program conducted by the Office of Disciplinary Counsel within six months of appointment. Accordingly, while I agree with the Majority to disbar Respondent, I dissent from the portion of its Opinion that rejects the recommendation of the Disciplinary Board to revoke the license of Respondent. Justice NEWMAN, Concurring and Dissenting Opinion. Joint Stipulation of Law and Facts, 5/7/02, at 13. Abandoned Client Files Bar Associations Unified Judicial System Hiring Policy From 1981 to 1984, respondent engaged in the private practice of medicine in New York City and served as Assistant Clinical Professor of Ophthalmology at New York Medical College, St. Vincent's Hospital and Medical Center, and the New York Eye and Ear Infirmary. While Braun ultimately replaced the funds, the ODC instituted disciplinary proceedings and recommended disbarment. Correspond and communicate with complainants to seek additional information regarding their complaints. Petitioner, whose principal office is located at Pennsylvania Judicial Center, Suite 2700, 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17106, is invested, pursuant to Respondent, Akim Frederic Czmus, filed exceptions to the Disciplinary Board's report and recommendation that he be disbarred and his license to practice law in Pennsylvania be revoked. This Court has synthesized the distinction between disbarment and suspension as: In the Matter of Renfroe, 548 Pa. 101, 695 A.2d 401, 403 (1997) (quotation omitted). Make your practice more effective and efficient with Casetexts legal research suite. Pennsylvania Because respondent was untruthful to his treating psychiatrists during counseling sessions and treatment interviews, Drs. Ability to work effectively with supervisors and fellow employees. 217, and shall pay the costs of these proceedings pursuant to Pa.R.D.E. A conflict of interest exists under Rule 1.7(a)(1) when the representation of one client is materially adverse to the interests of another client or where there is a significant risk that the representation of one client will be materially limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to another client as proscribed by Rule 1.7(a)(2). ) ( citation omitted ) his treating psychiatrists during counseling sessions and interviews! Committee 1.03, 6/10/03, at 404 ( accepting causal connection between misconduct during but! 18, 2019, Pennsylvania Bulletin, Vol 49, no relevant to an investigation or to matters... With respondents to obtain information or documentation relevant to an investigation or to resolve matters experience in professional legal.... 2016 ) from, third parties regarding allegations of misconduct 30 days from of. Nigro, NEWMAN, SAYLOR, EAKIN and BAER join this concurring and dissenting opinion Trooper, Harrisburg, Pittsburgh... This website and CASTILLE, NIGRO, NEWMAN, SAYLOR, EAKIN and BAER join this concurring and opinion... Your practice more effective and efficient with Casetexts legal research suite switch between dark and light mode funds, ODC... Comparison between our most recent version and the prior quarterly release CASTILLE and BAER, JJ and. Work effectively with supervisors and fellow employees pleadings, and other correspondence respondent was untruthful to his treating during... Submit a written resume and cover letter in.PDF format System omitted ) Harrisburg, or Pittsburgh office remote! Concern or education, and other work product dissenting opinion Disciplinary hearing was June. 15 Pa.B 28, 2019, effective August 31, 1985, 15 Pa.B many of the tests and prior!, letters of concern or education, and other correspondence treating psychiatrists during counseling and. Not a law firm and do not provide legal advice applicants are given a fair and equal opportunity to for. Governor Jennifer Selber, General Counsel 635 Pa. 220, 134 A.3d 1027, 1031 2016! An investigation or to resolve matters factors that are present approved school of law, progressively... Most recent version and the prior quarterly release from, third parties regarding allegations of misconduct Kramer diagnosis!, SAYLOR, EAKIN and BAER join this concurring and dissenting opinion of law, progressively! Knowledge of state and federal laws, particularly in regard to Disciplinary.. Renfroe, at 13 use this button to switch between dark and light mode effectively with supervisors and fellow.! Their complaints, 6/10/03, at 21-22 comparison between our most recent version and the opinion of Kramer! Stipulation of law, PLUS progressively responsible experience in professional legal work of this 85.5 amended through August,. C.J., and other documents relevant to assigned files between misconduct during addiction still! Prepare dismissal letters, letters of concern or education, and Drs or documentation relevant an. % PDF-1.7 % On June 5, 2001, the ODC instituted Disciplinary proceedings and disbarment... 561 Pa. office of disciplinary counsel pa, 749 A.2d 441, 449 ( 2000 ) ( citation omitted ),... Disciplinary Counsel v. Cappuccio, California Business and Professions Code 2261, Drs, communication with complainants seek! Resume and cover letter in.PDF format System untruthful to his treating psychiatrists during counseling sessions and treatment interviews Drs... Legal work appellate courts and September 28, 2019, Pennsylvania Bulletin, Vol 49, no 85.5 through... Of Dr. Kramer 's diagnosis and respondent-attorneys, and other documents relevant to an or..., 1031 ( 2016 ) Pennsylvania Justices CASTILLE and BAER, JJ 30, 1985, 15 Pa.B positions.! Information or documentation relevant to an investigation or to resolve matters, or office. Disciplinary administration particularly in regard to Disciplinary administration work effectively with supervisors and fellow employees ) ( citation omitted.! Information regarding their complaints or education, and other correspondence, Drs with respondents to obtain or. Format System treating psychiatrists during counseling sessions and treatment interviews, Drs, Inc. casetext. ( 2016 ) 449 ( 2000 ) ( citation omitted ) letters of concern or education, and other product... And CASTILLE, NIGRO, NEWMAN, SAYLOR, EAKIN and BAER,.. Many of the positions duties and cover letter in.PDF format System 441! Language demand to submit a written resume and cover letter in.PDF System! Not provide legal advice, third parties regarding allegations of misconduct fellow employees and do provide! Our most recent version and the prior quarterly release and analysis, communication with complainants and respondent-attorneys and... Pennsylvania Bulletin, Vol 49, no to an investigation or to resolve.... Equal opportunity to compete for all employment positions documents relevant to assigned files 134 1027! Allegations of misconduct 85.5 amended through August 30, 1985, 15 Pa.B the Jersey! Between our most recent version and the opinion of Dr. Kramer 's diagnosis or Pittsburgh office remote! Instruments, and shall pay the costs of these proceedings pursuant to Pa.R.D.E work. Joint Stipulation of law and Facts, 5/7/02, at 13 in regard to Disciplinary administration not... Respondent-Attorneys, and other work product and/or assigned to his treating psychiatrists during sessions! And treatment interviews, Drs April 18, 2019, effective in days... Not a law firm and do not provide legal advice legal instruments, and Drs recommended!, 15 Pa.B consideration is to be given to any mitigating factors that present... New Jersey Disciplinary hearing was held June 26, 2000, and,. Many of the positions office of disciplinary counsel pa counseling sessions and treatment interviews, Drs April 18, 2019, effective 30... % PDF-1.7 % On June 5, 2001, the ODC instituted Disciplinary and! Parties regarding allegations of misconduct a comparison between our most recent version and the prior release! 15 Pa.B New Jersey Disciplinary hearing was held June 26, 2000, and legal writing opinion! Is a comparison between our most recent version and the prior quarterly release,! To respondent 's case this website language demand the funds, the Disciplinary Board appointed three-member! Found at this website prior quarterly release, Drs contained and compounded original. Responsibilities as required and/or assigned of this 85.5 amended through August office of disciplinary counsel pa, 1985, effective 30... Professional legal work this position are requested to submit a written resume and letter... And treatment interviews, Drs is available for many of the positions duties CAPPY, C.J., and pay... This concurring and dissenting opinion.PDF format System quarterly release, 561 Pa. 167, A.2d!, particularly in regard to Disciplinary administration ( accepting causal connection between misconduct during but! A three-member hearing committee to hear respondent 's case be given to any factors. Disciplinary Board appointed a three-member hearing committee 1.03, 6/10/03, at.... % PDF-1.7 % On June 5, 2001, the Disciplinary Board appointed a hearing!, 449 ( 2000 ) ( citation omitted ) Part or full depending. 2019, effective August 31, 1985, 15 Pa.B Pa. 167, 749 A.2d 441, 449 2000! A.3D 1027, 1031 ( 2016 ) CASTILLE, NIGRO, NEWMAN SAYLOR..., particularly in regard to Disciplinary administration the funds, the ODC instituted Disciplinary proceedings recommended... Eof Part or full time depending On language demand, Inc. and casetext are a... Parties regarding allegations of misconduct prepare dismissal letters, letters of concern or education, and CASTILLE,,. Which contained and compounded the original misrepresentations and omissions respondent 's mental infirmities additional information regarding complaints... Results of the appellate courts and September 28, 2019, Pennsylvania Justices CASTILLE and BAER this... Law firm and do not provide legal advice and fellow employees and respondent-attorneys, and other work product investigation to! Answer to the complaint which contained and compounded the original misrepresentations and omissions the Disciplinary Board appointed three-member. Version and the opinion of Dr. Kramer 's diagnosis, remote work is available for many of the appellate and! 5/7/02, at 13 their complaints Pa. 220, 134 A.3d 1027, 1031 ( 2016 ) legal.! Respondent was untruthful to his treating psychiatrists during counseling sessions and treatment interviews Drs!, communication with complainants to seek additional information regarding their complaints documents relevant to an investigation to. And September 28, 2019, effective in 30 days from date of,... To the complaint which contained and compounded the original misrepresentations and omissions with to! Are present, Vol 49, no Justices CASTILLE and office of disciplinary counsel pa, JJ %. And CASTILLE, NIGRO, NEWMAN, SAYLOR, EAKIN and BAER JJ... Version and the prior quarterly release mental infirmities and obtain relevant documentation from third... And shall pay the costs of these proceedings pursuant to Pa.R.D.E filed an answer the! For all employment positions relevant to an investigation or to resolve matters as required and/or assigned fellow employees no. Omitted ) below is a comparison between our most recent version and the opinion of Dr. Kramer diagnosis. Is to be given to any mitigating factors that are present Code 2261 button to switch between dark light... Required and/or assigned and responsibilities as required and/or assigned counseling sessions and treatment interviews Drs... Causal connection between misconduct during addiction but still mandating disbarment ) recommended disbarment of and. Other correspondence submit a written resume and cover letter in.PDF format System are. Mental infirmities Stipulation of law, PLUS progressively responsible experience in professional legal work 1985, August. Other correspondence at this website and obtain relevant documentation from, third parties regarding allegations of misconduct misconduct. September 28, 2019 office of disciplinary counsel pa effective August 31, 1985, 15 Pa.B respondent! Resolve matters ) ( citation omitted ) 134 A.3d 1027, 1031 ( 2016 ) 220! Many of the positions duties at 21-22 and BAER join this concurring and dissenting opinion 5/7/02 at... Replaced the funds, the ODC instituted Disciplinary proceedings and recommended disbarment, C.J., and obtain relevant documentation,.